Picture a January morning on a steep side street, with packed snow under a thin glaze of ice. Your tires are the only parts of the car touching that road, and the rubber they're made of decides how fast you can stop. Picking the right set before the first big storm can save you a lot of tense miles.

How to Keep Your Grip on Beaver County's Snowy Hills

  • The National Weather Service lists 44.1 inches of average yearly snowfall at Pittsburgh International Airport, a short drive from Beaver County.

  • Winter tires use rubber that stays flexible below 45°F, while all-season rubber stiffens and loses grip as it gets colder.

  • In a Tire Rack ice test, winter tires stopped a Honda Civic from 12 mph in 35.1 feet, compared with 53.6 feet on all-season tires.

How Much Snow Falls Around Here

Our winters keep you guessing. Based on records from 1991 to 2020, the National Weather Service puts the yearly average at Pittsburgh International Airport at 44.1 inches. January is the snowiest month, with 13.3 inches, followed by February at 11.7 inches and December at 7.7 inches. Snow can show up as early as October and hang on into April.

Hilly roads, river valleys, and nights that refreeze afternoon slush turn even a light dusting into a slick commute. That's why it pays to weigh snow tires vs. all-season tires before winter settles in.

Cold Rubber Grips Less

Snow gets the attention, but temperature matters as much. Discount Tire explains that all-season rubber stiffens as temperatures drop, and once temperatures fall below 45°F, braking, acceleration, and cornering become less reliable. Winter tires use a tread compound built to stay soft and pliable below that mark.

A soft tire can press into tiny gaps in the road surface and hold on. Stiff rubber skates across the top.

What the Sidewall Tells You

Check your sidewall for two markings. All-season tires typically carry an M+S stamp. Tire Rack notes that M+S is based only on tread pattern shape and makes no promise about how the tire performs.

The Three Peak Mountain Snowflake symbol means more. A tire with that mark passed a set snow traction standard. Every winter tire carries it, but some all-season and all-terrain tires earn it too, so the symbol alone doesn't make a tire a winter tire.

Consumer Reports also points to all-weather tires, which are all-season tires with stronger cold-weather grip. They sit between the two groups and can stay on all year.

Stopping Distance on Ice

Tire Rack ran a side-by-side test on two 2012 Honda Civic EX sedans at an ice rink. One car wore studless winter tires, and the other wore touring all-season tires. From 12 mph, the winter tires stopped in 35.1 feet. The all-season tires needed 53.6 feet, about 18.5 feet more.

Getting started, the winter car covered 60 feet in about 4.5 seconds, while the all-season car took about 6 seconds. In a 90-degree turn, the winter tires held the line at 11 mph, and the all-season tires ran wide at that speed. Now picture that extra stopping room at a stop sign at the bottom of a hill.

Snow Tires vs. All-Season Tires Side by Side

Category

Winter / Snow Tires

All-Season Tires

Cold weather rubber

Tread compound stays flexible below 45°F

Compound stiffens and loses traction below 45°F

Sidewall marking

Always carries the Three Peak Mountain Snowflake symbol

Usually M+S, which is based on tread shape only. Some models also carry the snowflake symbol

Ice braking, 12 to 0 mph*

35.1 feet

53.6 feet

Ice acceleration, 60 feet*

4.508 seconds

6.045 seconds

Ice cornering limit, 90 degree turn*

11 mph

8 mph

Dry and wet road grip

Typically gives up some grip on clear roads

The better pick on dry and wet pavement

Tread life

Wears faster than all-season tires

Lasts longer

When you use them

Cold months only, swapped off in spring

Year round

Extra cost

A second set of tires and often a second set of wheels

None beyond normal replacement

Best fit

Best available grip in foul winter weather and below freezing

Performs well in more modest snow

*Tire Rack ice rink test, two 2012 Honda Civic EX sedans, studless winter tires vs. touring all-season tires. Other rows from Discount Tire, Tire Rack, and Consumer Reports.

What Winter Tires Cost You

Winter tires ask for a few trade-offs. According to Consumer Reports, they don't last as long as all-season tires and typically give up some grip on both dry and wet roads. Switching each year also means buying another set of tires and likely a second set of wheels to mount them on.

Worn all-season tires bring a different risk. The same group considers a tire worn out at 2/32 inch of tread and suggests shopping for new ones at 4/32 inch if you drive in winter. Its testing also shows all-season tires start losing traction in wet and wintry weather long before they look worn out.

Matching Tires to Your Winter Routine

Winter tires make the most sense if you leave for work before the plows finish, live on a steep street, or can't stay home when a storm rolls in. If your routes stay mostly flat and you can wait for cleared roads, a good set of all-season or all-weather tires with plenty of tread will handle most days. Check your tread now, before January's heavy snow shows up, and if the numbers look thin, our service center can measure it for you.

Winter Ready Rides at All Access Automotive

We stock used cars, trucks, and SUVs from a wide range of model years, so you can find something that fits your commute and your budget. Browse our current inventory to see what's on the lot. Our service center handles tire service, brake work, and PA state inspections, and we're happy to look at low tread or uneven wear before the next storm. Stop by, take a test drive, and get your next ride set up for the cold months ahead.

Snow Tire Questions We Hear Often

When should I put winter tires on?

Kelley Blue Book notes that many experts suggest switching once the average temperature stays below 45°F for a week, then taking them off when averages climb back above that mark in spring.

Are studded tires legal in Pennsylvania?

Yes, with a date limit. PennDOT allows studded snow tires from November 1 until April 15.

Do I need four winter tires or only two?

Go with four. Consumer Reports strongly recommends buying four winter tires for whatever vehicle you drive.

Is all-wheel drive enough with all-season tires?

All-wheel drive helps you get moving from a stop. In snow testing, though, Consumer Reports found it didn't aid braking or certain cornering situations, so your tires still do the stopping.

How do I know my all-season tires are too worn for winter?

Use a tread gauge. Consumer Reports treats 2/32 inch of tread as worn out and suggests shopping for new tires at 4/32 inch if you drive in winter weather.